Vote!

Vote for your favorite You Suck at Craigslist posts!


A little bit ago I posted an “8 suckiest Craigslist ads” page, and some ingrates beloved regular readers felt as though I left some of their favorite posts out.

Below are gathered, for your viewing pleasure, 28 of the best/worst ads that have appeared on You Suck at Craigslist. These 28 posts have undergone a rigorous selection process using an algorithm consisting of page counts, randomness, alcohol and nepotism. If I’ve missed one of your favorites, please put it in the comments below.

You can vote for up to 10 of the ads, and you can vote once every 24 hours. It doesn’t reset at midnight or anything fancy like that; I think it’s 24 hours from the last time you voted, for those of you who are planning to stuff the ballot box. The title of the post is a link to that post.

Which are YOUR favorite YSaC posts of all time?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
76 Responses leave one →
  1. 2010 July 16
    Meredith permalink

    It’s a REALLY tough call.

    Anyone remember some of the really bizarre early ones? There’s one with some sorta afroman dummy. At least I think there is..I could be imagining it.

    And wasn’t there a giant banana?

    I think some of the early ones were overlooked just because there weren’t a lot of us around then. But it’s what brought me out of the bushes.

    Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 16

      Giant banana: http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=2909

      Looking for the afroman dummy. I’d forgotten about that one.

      Found it! http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=2359 Guatsusnake!

      Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 16
        Meredith permalink

        There WAS an afroman dummy. For the life of me, I can NOT figure out what was going on there. And looking back on some of them, I can’t believe I’ve been coming here for so long. I’m very proud to know you bunch of hooligans!

        Adores: 0
  2. 2010 July 16
    mudslicker permalink

    Total responses under “50″ just blows whatever is left of my mind.

    Adores: 0
  3. 2010 July 16
    LurkRealClose permalink

    Yes, the giant inflatable banana companion is one of my favorites. He makes me laugh every time. Can we please add him?

    http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=2909

    Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 16

      I’ve added the giant banana (CSA share), guatsusnake (ice cream), and acrobactial midget (we represent …).

      Adores: 1
  4. 2010 July 16
    Moira permalink

    I re-read the giant banana one just yesterday. I am sure there will be a sudden ‘splosion of votes as our cadre of commenters finish reading over old posts and making their selection. I expect, also, a dramatic uptick of comments on old posts.

    Adores: 1
  5. 2010 July 16

    Okay, see, this is why I did this. The ones that are up here are a combination of most page views, most comments, and nepotism [a few that I just really liked and/or was proud of]. But I’d forgotten about some of the really weird ones, like guatsusnake … and those deserve to be seen! (She said modestly.)

    Keep the suggestions/vague recollections coming. Someone else on Twitter suggested the acrobactial midget post, which I’d completely forgotten about!

    Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 16
      LurkRealClose permalink

      Oh, yes, I’ve been re-reading old posts this week and all the midget ones are pretty calassay.

      Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 16
      TacoMagic permalink

      Oh gods, I forgot about that one too! I need to change my vote tomorrow.

      Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 16
      Moira permalink

      And thank you for making our Friday, nay, our WEEKEND that much more surreal. You do realize that now we will be on a scavenger hunt through the archives for the best snark of the past two years. :D

      Adores: 1
      • 2010 July 16

        That was my cunning plan.

        (It’s a plan so cunning you could stick a tail on it and call it a weasel!)

        Adores: 6
        • 2010 July 16
          TacoMagic permalink

          Nice Black Adder reference!

          *Swoon*

          Adores: 3
        • 2010 July 16

          Oh THAT’S what that was. I knew I recognized it…

          Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 16
      sarajean80 permalink

      How ’bout the one that spawned my favorite meme – the Cat Math post?

      Adores: 0
  6. 2010 July 16
    mudslicker permalink

    Okay, I voted but I missed seeing these:

    Unblubler:
    http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=4211

    Unique Magical Couch:
    http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=3399

    Boy Band Posters:
    http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=4303

    And my all time favorite:

    Free Pile:
    http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=3887

    Adores: 0
  7. 2010 July 16
    mudslicker permalink

    Apparently I posted [pending moderation] but I included too many links so I’m running down the few that I wish I had seen:

    Unblubler
    Unique Magical Couch [with accordion]
    Boy Band Posters
    Free Pile/Tas Gratuit

    I’m sure I’ll wake up at 2am with more suckage that puts me into a sweat.

    Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 16

      yes! unblubler and rontatooman were awesome.

      I have to also vote for “i can has vampire?” because I made it part of my English 101 syllabus.

      Lots of good posts, too many to count!

      Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 16

        I can has vampire?

        http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=1705

        Rontatooman:

        http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=2420

        Adores: 0
        • 2010 July 18

          I’m quite partial to “I can has vampire?” myself. In fact, when I’m telling someone they should read this blog, I often direct them to that post.

          Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 30
        christina permalink

        “I can has vampire” doesn’t get enough love in my opinion. That was the first post that had me laughing until it hurt.

        Adores: 0
        • 2010 July 30

          http://i30.tinypic.com/2drxavr.jpg

          I just clicked on the I can has Vampire? ad, and the above is the ad I got in the corner of the page.

          Cheap Twatlight knock-off MMORPGs are not what I expected.

          Adores: 0
        • 2010 July 30
          christina permalink

          I’ve been meaning to ask, why are comments closed on that one?

          Adores: 0
  8. 2010 July 16
    LurkRealClose permalink

    Painted by an angry badger?

    http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=2973

    Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 16

      I’d forgotten about that one too! I’ve added it.

      At this rate we’re going to have all 729 posts in the poll before too long!

      Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 16
        Addicted Reader permalink

        Well, they’re all awesome. That’s why we love this site.

        Adores: 3
  9. 2010 July 16
    Karmyn permalink

    I’m going to have to go with the original Not.A.Lion. But what’s the one where they think the snake crawled into the love seat and died? That was a good one, too.

    Adores: 0
  10. 2010 July 16
    mudslicker permalink

    We need the minty shell post.
    http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=3819

    It brought minty AND [corey] to our little YSaC family.

    Adores: 0
  11. 2010 July 16
    LimeLolly permalink

    This week the building next door has been undergoing painting and scrubbing. I missed seeing any of the work being done, because I’m covertly watching the port-a-john and wondering if there are snakes in there.

    Adores: 0
  12. 2010 July 16
    Moira permalink

    I have been TOTALLY unproductive today with the walk down memory lane going on. If I could just read the original post, it wouldn’t be so bad but NOOOOOO. I gotta read the comments, too.

    And then there’s the links to similar stuff.

    This is worse than wiki-diving.*

    *But far, far more satisfying.

    Adores: 2
    • 2010 July 16
      mudslicker permalink

      It’s virtual quicksand I tell you!

      Adores: 0
  13. 2010 July 16
    SilvaNoir permalink

    it only let me vote for one…. so I had to go with the truck full of bees.

    But yes, the catmath posts (especially steal this kitten), unblubler, and couch snake I think should make the list

    Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 16

      Huh. It lets me pick up to 10. Anyone else having voting issues?

      Edited to add: Er, it WOULD have allowed me to pick 10 if had been set to do so. *goes off grumbling about how she KNOWS she set that one correctly*

      When you vote in the future, it should allow you to vote for up to 10 of your favorites.

      Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 16
        mudslicker permalink

        It only let me pick one.

        Adores: 0
        • 2010 July 16

          Fixed. See above. *still grumbling*

          Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 16
        LurkRealClose permalink

        It let me vote for several, this morning. Then, it let me vote again because I’m on a different computer. Heh. Which is good, because I had earlier voted before the banana companion CSA share was added. And I love him.

        Adores: 1
  14. 2010 July 16
    Cindy B. permalink

    Database Fail Live (#333) still makes me laugh until I cry. I just watched it about 10 times in a row with my 5 year old and we were both falling on the floor with tears in our eyes (of course, it’s funny to us both for different reasons). I guess it’s my sense of humor, but it’s about the funniest thing I’ve seen on the internet.

    Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 16
      TacoMagic permalink

      It’s inspiring me towards making a video of the TacoThong dance.*

      What do you all think? Good idea?

      *This may not be true.

      Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 18
        SilvaNoir permalink

        nooooooooooooooooooooooo

        Not.A.Good.Idea

        Adores: 5
    • 2010 July 21
      Rhonda permalink

      ITA! I still laugh until I cry every time I watch that one again, too!

      Adores: 0
  15. 2010 July 16
    TacoMagic permalink

    Well, via a trip down memory lane (thanks to a combination of Moira, curiosity, the new voting section, and late night coffee) I found my very first post. It was in Vol 432: Like watching paint dry.

    http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=3145#comment-9862

    I can’t believe in my first outing I pulled a near Matt. The only reason I posted in the first place was that the craig’s sucker annoyed me with his use of LOL. If I hadn’t have been so annoyed I may not have ever started posting. Sorry folks, you were so very close to having a sane comments section.

    It wouldn’t be until 10 days later that I made my first trip to the box with the second ever appearance of the YSaC Haiku (Red table for sale). The first set of Haikus was in CXXIV: The Table.

    I also noticed in my trip that YSaCers have been correcting my spelling just about as long as I’ve been posting here. As much as things change, they stay the saim.

    *Looks at what he typed*

    Meh.

    Adores: 3
    • 2010 July 16
      Moira permalink

      Dammit. I had* to go reply in that thread after reading your post and the replies to it.

      *OCD – I compulsively share stupid personal stuff.

      Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 24

      I found my first post too.

      YSaC Home Movies: Astro’s First Post!

      I’d been lurking for weeks, and the only reason I’d hesitated was because I, at the time, had no idea why this Windrose person was randomly* punching people in the comments. Also, I only had a vague grasp on what you people were talking about.

      *I did not make the connection between Windrose and the Don’t Suck Box until my first trip into the Box.

      Adores: 0
  16. 2010 July 16

    My votes!


    Unblublers on mouses and avatars of kittens
    Jammin’ with oboes and warm door less fridges
    Mirrors with no imperfections or dings
    These are a few of my favorite things

    Sadistic dolls and old cans of Crisco
    Walls that drip blood and have undead echoes
    Inflatable Not.A.Lion until a leak it springs
    These are a few of my favorite things

    Dog tooth transplants and pink coffee tables
    Couples looking for midget acrobactials
    Plywood Santa sleighs to heavy for shipping
    These are a few of my favorite things

    When the pie ball dog bites
    When the truck bee stings
    When I’m feeling un-snarky
    I simply remember my favorite things
    And then I don’t feel so bad

    Adores: 7
    • 2010 July 17

      Um, HamCan, you do know about this, right?

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gGvHDmXfP18

      Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 17
        TacoMagic permalink

        I’ve been looking* for that link, thanks llama-nun!

        *In that I keep wondering about it then forgetting.

        Adores: 0
        • 2010 July 17

          And besides it was fun!

          Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 17
        Moira permalink

        That is beyond awesome!
        I have one request. Can we get lyrics on it? If you’re feeling really generous, can we get lyrics with a bouncing ball so we can sing along in proper karaoke style?

        And by “beyond awesome” I mean that Windrose did a fantastic mashup of recognizable memes and Jackie has a lovely voice. And, naturally, the pictures are the cherry on that sundae of awesomeness.

        Adores: 0
        • 2010 July 17
          Moira permalink

          (Oh, I see lyrics now – they just aren’t conveniently placed within the video. I’ll shut up and go sit in a corner now.)

          Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 17

        Nope, twisted minds think alike…

        My singing voice isn’t quite that good either :-D

        Adores: 0
      • 2010 July 17

        And besides it was fun
        (Other similar comment went in wrong spot, DOH!)

        Adores: 0
  17. 2010 July 17
    MandaB permalink

    Just reading the comments on the voting has me laughing hysterically. Now I have to go look at the posts? Oh my goodness, my sides hurt. I do love this site so!

    Adores: 0
  18. 2010 July 17
    PhantomBanker permalink

    Looking at the results so far, it appears the post in last place has “(2%, 1 Votes)”. Does that mean if it gets one more, it will have two voteses?

    Adores: 5
  19. 2010 July 19
    arallyn permalink

    Y HELLO THAR EVEERY BODY

    *cough* *cough*

    I mean, hey peeps! I’ve missed you all :( I’ve developed this…aversion to this website for some bizarre reason. For a while it made me feel the same way that thinking about yarn makes me feel (highly unpleasant, twitchy, gakky). But I think I’m over it…I hope D:

    Adores: 3
  20. 2010 July 19
    tigprincess permalink

    Where is 332? The octopussy garden? This was the post that stuck me to YSaC for life – and nearly stuck me to my monitor with eyes weeping and breath hard to come by. VOTE 332 ! please, pretty please?

    Adores: 1
  21. 2010 July 19

    I’ve always been partial to the human dildo one myself.

    Adores: 0
  22. 2010 July 19
    LurkRealClose permalink

    Yay! More votes for my favorite banana companion! #396, a strange CSA share.

    Adores: 0
  23. 2010 July 20

    The one with the truck full of bees has always been my favorite.

    Adores: 4
  24. 2010 July 23
    trinket permalink

    What about deep thinker? That’s one of my favorites. It’s just so

    Adores: 0
  25. 2010 July 23
    Aaron permalink

    Hypno Dogs!
    http://www.yousuckatcraigslist.com/?p=3468

    Adores: 0
  26. 2010 July 23
    Aaron permalink

    I mean you really can’t forget the Hypno Dogs bec— ALL HAIL THE HYPNO-DOGS

    Adores: 1
  27. 2010 July 24

    Okay, I have added in:

    Hypno-dog
    Loveseat with snake
    Can has vampire?
    Unblubler
    Unique magical couch (with accordion)
    Steal this kitten (the beginning of cat math)

    We’re up to a nice, round number of 37 options. You may still vote for up to 10 of your favorites, and can do so once every 24 hours. VOTE, DAMN IT!!

    Adores: 4
    • 2010 July 24

      When does the voting end? I need to know how much I can stuff the ballot love I can give my favorite posts.

      Adores: 4
      • 2010 July 24

        Whenever I, in my arbitrary and capricious manner, decide it is over.*

        *This may actually be true.

        Adores: 0
  28. 2010 July 24

    I didn’t realize how much I missed this until I tried to vote, and I can’t choose!
    Non-related: do you think I can absorb caffeine through my nasal cavities? Not much is reaching my stomach. Dunno why.

    Adores: 1
    • 2010 July 26

      Hey! Long time no see!

      Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 30

      You’re alive! Get your booty back to the comments right now, young lady! No one crosses the line quite like you do!

      Adores: 0
    • 2010 July 30
      Grampdaddy permalink

      Miss you, miss you, miss you! Nobody has told me I’ve “out-perved” them in ages!

      Adores: 0
  29. 2010 August 1

    Okay, After spending a very unproductive weekend re-reading these posts, I’d like to make a suggestion:
    Past postings=Sparchives
    Past comments=Snarchives

    Adores: 4
  30. 2010 August 3
    tigprincess permalink

    Help! I’ve voted for 8 only and the message says I can only vote for 10. If I add or subtract votes its still getting precious and insisting on 10. Technophobe here is giving up! xx

    Adores: 0
  31. 2010 August 4
    Gail permalink

    My all time favorite is ROOFER ROOFER ROOFER ROOFER ROOFER ROOFER ROOOFER ROOFER!

    Adores: 0
  32. 2010 August 6
    romana.klee permalink

    looking through these posts and the comments made me realize that i’ve read pretty much every post on the site….! philip glass sells a table is probably my all-time favorite. i do also love the unblubler, and the french canadian pile. (though the pile of crap post is bizarre and really cracks me up, a lot of the stuff mentioned in it does sound pretty rad and unsucky.) but my OTHER all-time favorite is the one about the snacks in the dumpster. i’m not really sure why i find that one so damn hilarious, i think because it’s really [an attempt at] philanthropy. ‘dude there’s like hundreds of bags in there….’

    Adores: 0

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

Easy AdSense by Unreal

Switch to our mobile site